When Luke Bryan leans forward in his chair and says, “You may win this whole thing,” the room on American Idol doesn’t just cheer — it freezes

american-idol-judges

Braden Rumfelt chose Sam Smith’s “I’m Not the Only One” for his Hollywood Week performance

NEED TO KNOW

  • Braden Rumfelt impressed the judges with his Hollywood Week performance of “I’m Not the Only One” on American Idol
  • Afterward, judge Luke Bryan declared he “may win”
  • Rumfelt auditioned to “Girl Crush” by Little Big Town

Did Luke Bryan just predict the next American Idol?

During the Monday, Feb. 23 episode of the singing competition show, the “Play It Again” singer was impressed by Braden Rumfelt’s Hollywood Week performance to Sam Smith’s “I’m Not the Only One” — and predicted a bright future for him on the show.

“Can you make it look harder next time? We knew you were special in your audition,” Bryan, 49, said to the 22-year-old North Carolina native.

LUKE BRYAN AMERICAN IDOL For the first time, Idol is bringing Hollywood Week to Music City as hopefuls take the stage for a make-or-break performance and face the biggest Hollywood Week cut in Idol history. MONDAY, FEB. 23(8:00-10:00 p.m. EST) on ABC.
Luke Bryan on American Idol in February 2026.Disney/Connie Chornuk

“We knew it, we felt it, we’re here to support you, we’re here to lift you up, we want you to have fun,” he continued. “Man, you picked the perfect song. Lean in, be you, be yourself and get ready for the ride. It’s gonna be really, really special.”

After he left the stage, Bryan looked at fellow judges Carrie Underwood and Lionel Richie and declared: “He may win.”

“But it seems like it’s gonna do well,” he said.

During his audition, Rumfelt brought his twin brother and sang “Girl Crush” by Little Big Town.

“I don’t know what I expected to come out of your mouth but that wasn’t it and it made me happy,” Underwood, 42, said, noting that he looked “really nervous” and he needed to loosen up.

BRADEN RUMFELT AMERICAN IDOL For the first time, Idol is bringing Hollywood Week to Music City as hopefuls take the stage for a make-or-break performance and face the biggest Hollywood Week cut in Idol history. MONDAY, FEB. 23
Braden Rumfelt on American Idol in February 2026.Disney/Connie Chornuk

“I think you’re a race horse man,” Bryan said, as Richie complimented the tone of his voice.

“He can sing ya’ll… You’ll do really good in this competition,” the “That’s My Kind of Night” singer said.

At the end of the Feb. 23 episode, Rumfelt’s future on the show remained on a cliffhanger. So far, the contestants to make it through Hollywood Week — and who have a chance at winning it all — are Bryant Thomas, Keyla Richardson, Makiyah, Jordan McCullough, Madison Moon, Roelle, Trace Casanova, Hannah Harper, Philmon Lee, Lucas Leon, Kiera Howell, Abayomi and Michael Garner.

American Idol airs Mondays at 8 p.m. ET on ABC.

0 Shares:
Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

My coworkers mocked me for spending my last $10 on a homeless man. “Why waste money on him?” they laughed. I ignored them, but then the restaurant owner stormed out. He froze, staring at the dirty stranger. “Dad?” he whispered, tears falling. The room went dead silent. He turned to me with a sealed box. “Open it,” he choked out. I looked inside and gasped…

Chapter 1: The Invisible Divide They say Seattle is a city of innovation, a place where the future…